My Mortgage Is Renewing After a Pandemic-Era Rate. What Should I Do First?

October 6, 2026

When you go to your bank to renew your rate from your pandemic mortgage, get a second opinion before you sign anything. Your bank will offer you what works for your bank. Start the conversation about 120 days out and treat it as a strategy conversation rather than a rate conversation.

If you locked in during 2020 or 2021, you do not need an economist to tell you what is coming. You took a rate that started with a one or a two. You are renewing into a market where five year fixed rates generally start with a three or a four. Your payment is going up.

The question is not “if”, it is “by how much” and what you do about it.

You are not alone in this

The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation projects roughly 1.15 million Canadian mortgages renewing in 2026, with another 940,000 in 2027. This is the largest renewal wave the country has seen, and it exists because so many people locked into five year terms when rates were at historic lows.

Why does that matter to you? Because lenders know it is happening too. There is competition for renewal business right now, and competition is leverage. It only works if you use it.

Your bank is going to offer you what is good for your bank

I want to be fair about this rather than cynical. Banks and credit unions are publicly traded companies with shareholders. Their job is to make money. When your renewal letter shows up with a rate on it, that rate reflects what makes sense for them.

Nobody at that institution is going to sit you down and walk you through how to pay them less money. That isn’t their job. But, it is mine.

So get a second opinion. Always. Even if you end up staying exactly where you are, you will at least know what you are choosing rather than defaulting into it.

Start 120 days out

You can usually start the renewal process about 120 days before your maturity date, and that window exists for your benefit.

Inside that window you can shop, get rate holds, and switch lenders without penalty. Outside of it your options narrow fast. If you wait until three weeks before maturity, you have effectively removed your own leverage, and the offer in front of you becomes the only offer you have time to consider.

So if your term matures in January, you should be having this conversation in September. If it matures in March, start around November.

It is not only about the rate

When someone books a renewal call with me and opens with what rate can you get me, my first question back is usually about something else.

What is your cash flow situation? Has your income changed? Is there consumer debt sitting outside the mortgage that is eating your monthly budget? Are you planning to move in the next two years? Do you want to be mortgage free faster, or do you need breathing room right now?

Those answers change the recommendation completely. Sometimes the right move is a shorter term. Sometimes it is folding outside debt into the mortgage to fix cash flow. Sometimes it is keeping the payment where it is and shortening the amortization because you are earning more now.

Sometimes it genuinely is just the best rate available.

125a Russell Ave, St. Catharines, ON L2R 1W1
© 2026 Tyler Hibbs Mortgage Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Mortgage Architects Agent # M19000340 Brokerage #12728
Website Designed and Hosted by Giant Shoe Creative Agency